WHY CHOOSE COMPRESSORS
TO TRANSFER LPG AND TWO-PHASE LIQUIDS
IN STORAGE DEPOTS
The use of compressors for the transfer of LPG and two-phase
liquids in storage depots is a consolidated practice in the most
experienced technologies of the gas field.
Actually compressors present a wide set of advantages which makes
them preferred to pumps in the loading and unloading operations
of two-phase fluids.
First of all, compressors eliminate any pump suction concerns
in situations where there is low or negative NPSH (Net Positive
Suction Head) availability. These situations would include typical
railcars or other tanks which have no openings on the bottom of
the tanks or a low NPSH. Actually, trying to pump out of a tank
with only top openings will result in very poor pump suction conditions
and very short vane and seal life. Moreover the pump would be
very noisy and as the liquid is withdrawn form such a vessel,
the pump suction conditions would continually worsen throughout
the process until eventually the pump can no longer function.
Considerably liquid would be left in the vessel and this might
be 20 or 30 percent of its capacity.
After removing all of liquid from a vessel, a compressor can
then also remove vapour, while a liquid pump could never truly
empty an LPG vessel. Actually even if it pumps all of the liquid
out, the vessel would still be full of vapour at vapour pressure.
The remaining vapour can equal about 3% of the tanks total capacity.
This means that fewer loads will be required for the same overall
capacity when compared with using a pump to do the transfer operation.
Anytime a vessel must be opened to atmosphere, a compressor is
the method of choice. If the vessel is going to be opened for
inspection or repair, then all of the liquid or vapour must be
removed from it before any work can proceed. Due to environmental,
safety or economic concerns, this product cannot be vented to
the atmosphere nor can a pump be used to recover the product.
A compressor will handle these situations readily.
Some vessels have no openings at all into the liquid section
of the tank. Typical home delivery tanks of under 2.000 litres
(500 gallons) and typical small cylinders, such as the 5 kilograms
(20 pound), only have a single opening in the top of the vessel.
Also, the trucks or railcars that have been involved in accidents
may be lying on their side such that none of the normally used
openings in to the tank connect to the liquid section. In any
of these situations, a liquid pump would be
totally useless in trying to empty the vessel. Compressors, on
the other hand, can easily handle all of these situations while
the very best that a pump can do is to empty a vessel of liquid
but still leaving it full of vapour. A compressor can always empty
a tank of all the liquid and then proceed to empty the tank of
virtually all the vapour.
Since pumps must be provided with properly designed suction lines,
that may be impossible to do with many vessels. A compressor on
the other hand is not subject to these limitations. A compressor
can recover both the liquid and the vapour form virtually any
vessel under virtually any situation.
Finally, even though the initial cost for a compressor is of
course higher than the cost for a pump, the average life of a
compressor is three or four times that of a pump and its maintenance
operations are carried out less frequently.
With compressors the plant costs too will be reduced because
the storage tanks can be installed at the ground level or just
under since compressors don't need NPSH.
It results clear that compressors are much better than pumps
for the unloading operations. Moreover, with an appropriate hose
system, the same compressor can be used for loading and unloading
operations. Otherwise two similar machines can be installed working
without distinction for loading and unloading, thus giving the
possibility to carry out these two operations simultaneously.
WHEN TO USE COMPRESSORS AND PUMPS TOGETHER
There are situations where the best solution is to use both a
pump and a compressor working together to transfer the LPG. The
most common of these situations would be where the pump would
be faced with poor suction conditions and the compressor would
be faced with high differential pressure conditions.
A typical installation requiring both a pump and a compressor,
would be a railcar unloading operation in which the railcar and
the storage tank are separated by a longer than normal distance.
Also, the storage tank might be located at a higher elevation
than the railcar. In these situations, a pump can be used to build
high differential pressures needed to push the liquid up to the
storage tank, but would have an extremely difficult time in withdrawing
the liquid from the top of the railcar, while a compressor would
be used to push the liquid out of the tank car easily enough.
Of course, after all the liquid has been removed from the railcar,
then the compressor shall be also used by itself to recover the
WHY CHOOSE COMPRESSOR TO TRANSFER LPG
AND TWO-PHASE LIQUIDS IN STORAGE DEPOTS
Ø CAN TRANSFER ALL THE PRODUCT, BOTH LIQUID & VAPOR
Ø ARE NOT SUBJECT TO POOR PUMP SUCTION PROBLEMS OR LINE
Ø CAN EMPTY ALL KIND OF VESSELS IN EVERY SITUATION
Ø HAVE A VERY LONG LIFE AND NEED A FEW MAINTENANCE OPERATIONS
Ø CAN LOAD AND UNLOAD SIMULTANEOUSLY
- OFFER POOR SUCTION CONDITIONS WITH TOP OPENINGS TANKS AND
o- SHORT VANE AND SEAL LIFE
o- NOISY OPERATIONS
- LEAVE CONSIDERABLE LIQUID QUANTITIES IN THE TANK
- HAVE A HIGHER POWER CONSUMPTION
- LEAVE ALL TANK FULL OF VAPOR
o- EQUALS 3% OF TOTAL TANK CAPACITY
- CANNOT BE USED IN VESSELS WITH NO LIQUID OPENINGS
o- HOME DELIVERY TANKS (UNDER 2.000 LT)
o- TRUCKS OR RAIL CARS INVOLVED IN ACCIDENTS
WHEN TO USE PUMPS AND COMPRESSORS TOGETHER
- IN CASE OF POOR PUMP SUCTION CONDITIONS + HIGH DIFFERENTIAL
- IN CASE OF RAIL CAR AND STORAGE VESSEL SEPARATED BY:
o- UNDERSIZED PIPIN